Robbie Williams Defends Olivia Rodrigo, Calls Song-Similarity Claims ‘Ambulance Chasing’

Posted

Over the last decade and a half we’ve seen a flood of very stupid copyright lawsuits, often from old, washed-up artists (or worse, their estates), demanding money from younger artists because new songs have some similarities — a feel, a melodic snippet, the same chord progression, whatever. The worst example of this, obviously, was the infamous Blurred Lines case, which ended stupidly, and kicked off a bunch of other similar lawsuits (many of which haven’t been as successful). It’s gotten so ridiculous that some artists now film their entire writing process in case they later have to go to court to defend their creative process.

Anyway, it looked like we might be getting another one of those silly situations when some people started pointing out that Olivia Rodrigo’s recent release, take me home (4 christmas), sounds similar to Robbie Williams’s Candy, from back in 2012. Of course, making this even more complicated is that Rodrigo has said her song was inspired by the 1981 song Christmas Wrapping from the band The Waitresses, and claims she spoke to that band’s Christopher Butler before writing her own song.

What usually happens next is that the online murmurings get louder and louder until the older artist finally says or does something — often demanding a cut of the royalties. But this time, Robbie Williams did something different: he published a rant (in image form on Instagram) defending Rodrigo while knocking musicians who rush to “go after” anyone whose songs sound a bit like their own.

Since reading text in images is perhaps the most annoying way to do anything, I’ve transcribed his 4 image rant below:

There’s something about the music industry that’s been bothering me for a while.

People coming after people because they’ve spotted a similarity between two songs.

Some of it I completely understand. Some of it is absolutely justified.

Most of it, I think, is complete bollocks.

I’ve had plenty of people come after me over the years because something I’ve released apparently sounds like something somebody else released.

And sometimes I listen and think, fair enough, I can hear that.

Other times I think, are you having a fucking laugh?

There are only so many notes. Only so many chords. Only so many ways of putting them together before you inevitably find yourself somewhere somebody else has been.

Music has been around for a very long time.

We’re all going to bump into each other eventually.

Which brings me to Olivia Rodrigo.

I love Olivia Rodrigo.

I’ve loved her since Brutal. What a fucking record. I wish I’d made it.

Also, I cannot believe how much she swears on stage. And that’s coming from me. I’m a Sweary Mary, but she’s making me look like a Victorian schoolmistress.

Anyway.

It sounds to me as though she may have accidentally stumbled across a musical echo of mine in one of her new songs.

And do you know what?

I couldn’t care less.

I don’t know whether there’s technically a publishing issue, a copyright issue, or no issue whatsoever.

And I don’t want to know.

I’m not going after her.

Because I think at some point, some fucking sanity has to prevail.

Now, I appreciate I’m in a position in my career where I can afford to take that view. Not everybody is. And genuine theft is genuine theft. Artists deserve to be protected. But there’s a difference between protecting your work and treating every vaguely familiar sequence of notes as a winning lottery ticket.

Some of this stuff has become ambulance chasing.

And I think it’s disgusting.

We all stand on the shoulders of people who came before us. Sometimes consciously. Sometimes without even knowing it.

That’s how music works.

If we keep punishing people for accidentally arriving somewhere somebody else has already been, eventually we’re going to frighten the creativity out of everyone.

Anyway.

Olivia, if you’re reading this, I think you’re fucking brilliant. But please stop swearing so much.

It makes me feel like I have to keep up.

And frankly, I’m already swearing far more than is necessary.

Lots of love and Happy Christmas

Rob x

There are a bunch of good points there (some of which we’ve made before), including that this is how music works. Almost all musicians start out by imitating their favorite artists and then learning how to add their own style and signature to the music. Sometimes they add in bits as an homage. Sometimes they just do it accidentally because — as Robbie notes — there are only so many notes (and even fewer combinations of them that actually sound good together).

Of course there may be some complicating factors. Williams can say all of that, but it looks like there may be other copyright interests in the song, considering that he co-wrote it with some others, and it includes a riff from a different song (from one of the people listed as a co-author of Candy, Terje Olsen). It’s also not clear if Williams owns his own publishing, and publishing companies can be especially annoying. And that’s not even getting into the complications regarding the 1981 song by The Waitresses as well.

It’s also worth noting that Rodrigo has had to give up royalties to other artists in the past as well, which some are suggesting means that Rodrigo “has a history” of this kind of thing, but to me suggests (again) that lots of music borrows ideas — consciously or unconsciously from others — and people should just be more chill about it. Like Robbie Williams here.

In this era when everyone wants to lawyer up and demand things, it’s always nice when someone just comes out and says “yo, this is fucking crazy, I don’t want any part of it, the music is great, can we please just enjoy that.”

1, blurred lines, copyright, inspiration, music, olivia rodrigo, robbie williams